New Earnings Test Data: Only 2% of College Degree Programs at Risk

Education Department Releases Latest Accountability Data

Access the complete dataset

The HEA Group has analyzed all 38,301 undergraduate programs in the dataset. Our analysis includes:

  • Graduate earnings by program
  • High school earnings benchmarks
  • Each program’s risk status for federal aid eligibility
  • Data presented in an accessible, user-friendly format
2%of degree programs are at risk804 of 32,578 associate and bachelor’s programs
29%of certificate programs fail1,659 of 5,723 undergraduate certificate programs
14%of degree programs earn $50K+ above high school grads4,411 programs serving 435,722 graduates

By Michael Itzkowitz

January 5, 2026

On December 30, 2025, the Education Department released new data determining which college degree programs may remain eligible to participate in the federal student loan program. Under the proposed rule, undergraduate programs must demonstrate that the majority of students who obtain a credential earn more than a typical high school graduate with no college experience. The Department has proposed applying this standard to all undergraduate programs, regardless of institutional sector, and negotiations take place from January 5-9, 2026.

Key Findings

Only 804 out of 32,578 associate and bachelor-degree granting programs (~2%) are at risk of failing this test. These programs graduate 40,693 students out of 2,537,760 total students in the dataset. Comparatively, 1,659 out of 5,723 undergraduate certificate programs (29%) fail to meet this benchmark, meaning the majority of their completing students fail to earn more than someone with no college experience, even four years after attending.

By contrast, 4,411 associate and bachelor degree programs (~14%) perform exceptionally well, with graduates earning at least $50,000 more than typical high school graduates within four years of completing their credential, representing 435,722 students. Nearly 140 undergraduate certificate programs also show their graduates earning this strong premium.

Program-level data

Which programs pay off, and which are at risk

Earnings four years after completion, compared with the earnings benchmark each program must beat under the new earnings test.

Source: HEA Group analysis of U.S. Department of Education data. Earnings are median earnings four years after completion; graduates are completers in the earnings cohort. Download all 38,301 programs →

What’s Next?

The HEA Group will continue monitoring these developments and tracking issues affecting higher education institutions nationwide.

For questions about these data or analysis, please contact us.

*This has been updated to reflect that 4,411 associate and bachelor degree programs show their graduates earning at least $50,000 more than the typical high school graduate.


 
Summary Block
This block has no content yet. Items you add to the page connected to this block will display here.
Previous
Previous

HEA Group Partners with ACCJC on Strategic Use of Program-Level ROI Data

Next
Next

Is College Still Worth It? The Harlan Cohen Podcast with Michael Itzkowitz