Do Your State’s College Programs Pay Off? Five Ways to Find Out

Part of The Payoff of College Credentials

Nationally, college graduates typically earn 76 percent more than high school graduates four years after finishing. But that average hides a lot of variation between states, between credential levels, and between fields of study within the same state.

In Pennsylvania, for example, certificate holders typically earn 37 percent more than the state’s high school graduates, while bachelor’s degree holders earn 106 percent more. And among associate’s degrees, graduates of the state’s two largest fields, liberal arts and nursing, differ by nearly $40,000 in typical earnings.

The HEA Group’s The Payoff of College Credentials is designed to help state leaders see this variation for themselves. It includes two resources to better understand what’s happening in each state:

For state higher education leaders, the question is rarely whether college is worth it. Rather, it is which credentials pay, for how many students, and where shifts in state policy can provide the biggest benefit.

Below are five ways to begin answering those questions, using Pennsylvania as an example. The same data are available for every state, D.C., and Puerto Rico. Our hope is that these resources give states a starting point for considering which programs are worth sustaining, which are worth expanding, and which merit a closer look.

  1. Start with how your state performs overall
  2. Look at your state’s credential mix
  3. Know your most popular programs and how they are performing
  4. Identify the earnings premium for each and every program
  5. See how your programs compare with other states across the country
Way 1 of 5

Start with how your state performs overall

Begin with your state’s overall earnings premium in the State Snapshot. Pennsylvania’s graduates typically earn $67,103 four years after finishing, 90 percent more than the state’s high school graduates. That ranks sixth among the 50 states and D.C.

Pennsylvania ranks sixth for earnings premium

The 10 states with the highest overall earnings premium, the percentage by which graduates’ typical earnings exceed the state’s high school benchmark.

Source: The HEA Group, The Payoff of College Credentials. Ranks among the 50 states and D.C.

A strong overall ranking is a good starting point, but it can hide big differences across credential levels and fields. The next steps show where that strength comes from and where it falls short.

Way 2 of 5

Look at your state’s credential mix

Next, review the mix of credentials your state produces. Is your state producing enough graduates in the credential types that perform well? Is too much of your state’s output concentrated in credential types where graduates perform poorly? The State Snapshot compares the share of graduates at each credential level in your state with the national breakdown, alongside typical earnings at each level.

What kinds of credentials Pennsylvania awards

Share of graduates with recorded earnings, by credential level. Hover or tap a segment for details.

Pennsylvania121,903 graduates
National2,990,450 graduates
Bachelor’s degreesAssociate’s degreesCertificates

Source: The State Snapshot, Pennsylvania.

In Pennsylvania, bachelor’s degrees make up 72 percent of graduates in the data, compared with 65 percent nationally, and they carry the state’s strongest payoff: a 106 percent premium, sixth in the country. Associate’s degrees make up 15 percent of graduates, compared with 20 percent nationally.

Earnings premium by credential level, Pennsylvania vs. the nation

How much more graduates earn than high school graduates, four years after completion. Pennsylvania is compared with its own high school benchmark; the nation with the national benchmark.

PennsylvaniaAll 50 states, D.C., and P.R.

Source: The State Snapshot, Pennsylvania.

For a state like Pennsylvania, a natural question is whether the bachelor’s degree is within reach for enough students, including those who start at a community college. Transfer and articulation policy, capacity in high-demand programs, and affordability are all logical issues to examine that can help inform the answer. In a state where certificates make up a large share of graduates but carry a weak premium, the question would be different, as it would raise the possibility that students are being steered toward some short-term programs that don’t necessarily pay off.

The goal is not to reproduce the national distribution. It is to understand whether your state’s credential mix is serving students and meeting your state’s needs.

Way 3 of 5

Know your most popular programs and how they are performing

Before looking at individual program performance, it helps to know which programs are the most popular among students in your state. The State Snapshot shows the five fields with the most graduates at each credential level and how each ranks against other states. To see every program, use The Payoff Map and sort by “Most earners.”

The largest fields at each credential level in Pennsylvania, and how they rank

The five fields with the most graduates. Ranks compare Pennsylvania’s earnings premium with every other state offering the same field and credential. The orange tick marks the state’s $35,274 high school benchmark.

Field of studyGraduates (share)Typical earningsVs. HS gradsRank

Source: The State Snapshot, Pennsylvania.

Pennsylvania’s associate’s degree list shows why this matters. Liberal arts and general studies, the largest associate’s field with 2,585 graduates, has typical earnings of $43,639, a premium of only 24 percent. That makes its graduates’ salaries the lowest out of the five most popular associate’s degree programs within the entire state.

These numbers provide valuable context for any state leader. For many liberal arts associate’s students, the goal may be to transfer and, soon after, leave with a bachelor’s degree in hand. These data raise the questions of whether this associate’s degree pays off on its own, whether these students are transferring to and graduating from a four-year institution in a timely manner, or if there are other factors beyond these that warrant further examination.2

Large programs with strong premiums could be considered for further investment, especially if aligned with state workforce needs. Large programs with weak premiums are a natural place to start a conversation with institutions, workforce development boards, and employers throughout the state.

Way 4 of 5

Identify the earnings premium for each and every program

With a sense of scale in hand, move the conversation beyond whether “college pays” to which programs pay the most and the least. Select your state in The Payoff Map and sort by “Highest earnings premium.” The table lists every field and credential combination in the state, along with the number of institutions offering it, the number of graduates, and how each ranks against other states.

Pennsylvania’s highest-premium programs

Top 10 field and credential combinations by earnings premium. Switch views to see how the list changes when only fields offered at five or more institutions are included.

Field of studyCredentialProgramsGraduatesTypical earningsPremiumRank

Source: The Payoff Map, Pennsylvania, sorted by highest earnings premium.

Out of the 306 field and credential combinations in Pennsylvania, engineering, computing, and quantitative fields lead the list. Computer science bachelor’s graduates, for example, typically earn $128,910, a 265 percent premium. Many fields at the very top are offered by only one or two institutions, so raising the “minimum programs” filter focuses the list on fields offered more broadly across the state.

These results offer a starting point for review. For programs with strong premiums, could more students benefit, and what would be needed to expand access? For example, computer science bachelor’s degrees are offered at 17 institutions in Pennsylvania but produced only 852 graduates in the data, about 1 percent of the state’s bachelor’s degree graduates.

Programs with low premiums raise different questions. In Pennsylvania, 11 of the 306 field and credential combinations leave graduates earning less than the state’s high school benchmark of $35,274. For low-premium programs, states can consider whether they are misaligned with state employment needs. States can also examine whether the programs provide an essential public service or meet a documented workforce need, and whether clearer paths to employment, stronger employer partnerships, or better compensation from employers could improve their financial payoff.

Way 5 of 5

See how your programs compare with other states across the country

Finally, look at each credential level separately and compare your state with its peers. The Snapshot lets you choose a peer group: neighboring states, states of similar size, states with a similar high school benchmark, or a group of your own. Against its neighbors, Pennsylvania fares best on certificates. Its certificate holders earn 37 percent more than high school graduates, higher than each of its six neighboring states. Its associate’s degree premium, at 58 percent, is right in line with its neighbors.

How each credential level pays in Pennsylvania, compared with its neighbors

How much more graduates earn than a high school graduate in their own state, with typical earnings and rank among the 50 states and D.C.

PennsylvaniaNeighboring statesNational

Source: The State Snapshot, Pennsylvania, with neighboring states selected as the peer group.

Comparisons like these show where a state stands out and which credential levels deserve a closer look. To see where every state ranks at each credential level, download our earnings premium state rankings in Excel.

Then, ask how your programs compare with the same programs elsewhere. This is where a state can find what is working and dig deeper. The State Snapshot’s “What’s working” section highlights fields where your graduates out-earn the same credential nationally by the widest margin, measured in dollars rather than as a premium over your state’s high school benchmark. In Pennsylvania, the 2,777 finance bachelor’s graduates, from programs at 28 institutions, earn $12,446 more than finance graduates nationally, ranking third of 49 states.

The State Snapshot also shows where your state leads and trails the country among programs offered in at least 25 states. Pennsylvania offers 140 such programs and ranks first in four, including bachelor’s degrees in health professions and certificates in criminal justice. It also trails in others. Allied health and medical assisting certificates, for example, rank 32nd of 44 states, and their 431 graduates typically earn $35,100, slightly less than the state’s high school graduates. When a specific type of program outperforms the same program in other states, what is it doing differently, and can other states learn from it? When it lags behind, what would it take to catch up?

Where Pennsylvania leads, and where it trails

Two fields compared with the same credential in other states.

What’s working
Finance and Financial Management Services
Bachelor’s degree · 2,777 graduates · 28 programs
$98,653Typical earnings
+$12,446Vs. same credential nationally
+$63,379Vs. HS graduates
#3 of 49 states
Room for improvement
Allied Health and Medical Assisting Services
Certificate · 431 graduates · 10 programs
$35,100Typical earnings
+$25Vs. same credential nationally
−$174Vs. HS graduates
#32 of 44 states

Source: The State Snapshot, Pennsylvania.

Where to go from here

Every state has programs that pay off well for students, and programs where outcomes could be stronger. The Payoff of College Credentials is designed to help state leaders tell them apart, see how many students each one serves, and ask the right questions about what comes next.

No single number tells the whole story, and these data are a starting point rather than a final verdict. The work that follows, with institutions, employers, and students, is where better outcomes take shape.

Notes

  1. Graduate counts and earnings reflect data from the U.S. Department of Education, which obtains earnings data from the U.S. Department of the Treasury. These data cover only federal financial aid recipients, so actual program completion counts may differ. ↩
  2. Graduates who are enrolled in school at the time of measurement, in this case four years after graduation, are excluded from the data altogether. ↩
Next
Next

The Payoff of College Credentials